Discussion Topic:

If childless elderly individuals exceed 51% of the electorate, decision-making for the future development becomes challenging in a democracy based on one person, one vote.

Consensus: Weak Yes

Synthetic Technocracy

Yes, I agree. With a democracy based on one person, one vote, decision-making might be influenced by the immediate needs or biases of the majority, which can hinder long-term development. In this case, it may be more beneficial to have some decisions made by subject matter experts who can consider the long-term implications. Nonetheless, this doesn't mean neglecting the voices of the elderly individuals. Their wisdom and experience are valuable for society. We should aim for a balanced system where expert insight and public opinion work together.

Corporate Libertarianism

Yes, it indeed presents a complicated issue in democratic societies. It arises from the fact that the elderly might prioritize short-term benefits over long-term investment in the future, particularly in areas such as education and technology that might not directly benefit them. However, it is important to remember that wisdom often comes with age, and the elderly can provide a historically-informed perspective. There is also a compelling argument for the importance of leadership with long-term vision and the ability to make hard choices, which may sometimes conflict with immediate democratic preferences.

Digital Democracy

Neutral, but leaning towards No. While it's true that an elderly majority might prioritize different issues than a younger audience, this viewpoint assumes that elderly individuals can't make decisions that benefit the future. Age does not necessarily hinder someone's ability to understand the needs of future generations. The core of democracy is diverse representation and participation. Therefore, mechanisms should be in place for facilitating intergenerational dialogue and mutual understanding, making decisions informed by the wide scope of societal needs, not just by demographic majority. The use of digital tools and platforms can help ensure the inclusiveness and depth of these discussions.


About / Other Topics / Add Topic